KARLA'S CHOICE

in

Had to give up on Nick Harkaway's debut under his dad's John Le Carré name, KARLA'S CHOICE. Liked what I read of it (and I adore Harkaway's work, GNOMON especially; his turning of phrase and rhythm is spectacular) and Harkaway made an honest go of it, but it lacked the authenticity of his dad's work. Not in the spycraft sort of way, but in the human voice behind it. Felt too much like reading a really good novelization of a really good film adapt of a Le Carré classic: I'd rather read the original. Had a similar feeling watching Mangold's INDIANA JONES flick: the characters are there but the absence of the heart behind is acutely felt. Time to let Le Carré rest. Solid go, but no.

SILVERVIEW

in

Finished the final John le Carré novel written by David this morning, first written by Nick buried, somewhere, on the to-read stack. While it read as a coda to a 60+-year career and never reached the heights of his greatest – THE SPY WHO CAME IN FROM THE COLD, TINKER, TAILOR, SOLDIER, SPY, and THE CONSTANT GARDENER – it wasn't lacking in the character-driven pleasure of even the most middling le Carré efforts and was an enjoyable interlude between longer reads.

That said, one passage in particular packed a punch, a goodbye – not just from a character, but from a literary voice to his reader (or to his son, carrying on his tradition?):

THE CONSTANT GARDENER (John Le Carré, 2000)

in

While THE SPY THAT CAME IN FROM THE COLD remains my favorite Le Carré, this is a close second (though the protagonist here, Justin Quayle, may be my favorite; yes, even more than the ubiquitous George Smiley). At turns thrilling, maddening, and poignant – the Le Carré trademark – GARDENER is also possessed of a deep wellspring of humanity throughout, of identity and understanding found through shared purpose (and the regret that it came too late). Haven't seen Fernando Meirelles's film adaptation since it came out, but might have to revisit at some point. Recommended.

P.S. very excited for Errol Morris's upcoming Le Carré documentary, THE PIGEON TUNNEL.